Skip to main contentSkip to solution

If R and S are two equivalence relations on a set A, then

Solution

Correct Option: 3

An equivalence relation on a set A is a relation that satisfies three properties:

Reflexive: Every element relates to itself, (a,a)R(a,a) \in R for all aAa \in A

Symmetric: If (a,b)R(a,b) \in R, then (b,a)R(b,a) \in R

Transitive: If (a,b)R(a,b) \in R and (b,c)R(b,c) \in R, then (a,c)R(a,c) \in R

All three properties must hold for a relation to be an equivalence relation.


Consider RSR \cap S (the intersection of R and S).

For reflexive: Since both R and S are reflexive, (a,a)(a,a) is in both R and S. Therefore (a,a)RS(a,a) \in R \cap S.

For symmetric: If (a,b)RS(a,b) \in R \cap S, then (a,b)(a,b) is in both R and S. Since both are symmetric, (b,a)(b,a) is in both R and S. Therefore (b,a)RS(b,a) \in R \cap S.

For transitive: If (a,b)RS(a,b) \in R \cap S and (b,c)RS(b,c) \in R \cap S, then both pairs are in R and in S. Since both R and S are transitive, (a,c)(a,c) is in both R and S. Therefore (a,c)RS(a,c) \in R \cap S.

Therefore RSR \cap S is an equivalence relation.


For any equivalence relation, the inverse relation is also an equivalence relation due to the symmetric property. If (a,b)(a,b) is in the relation, then (b,a)(b,a) is already present. Taking the inverse simply reflects the relation.

Since RSR \cap S is an equivalence relation, (RS)1(R \cap S)^{-1} is also an equivalence relation.


Consider RSR \cup S (the union of R and S).

Transitivity can fail for the union.

Counter-example: Let (a,b)R(a,b) \in R but (a,b)S(a,b) \notin S. Let (b,c)S(b,c) \in S but (b,c)R(b,c) \notin R. Then both (a,b)(a,b) and (b,c)(b,c) are in RSR \cup S. However, (a,c)(a,c) may not be in either R or S, so (a,c)(a,c) may not be in RSR \cup S.

Therefore RSR \cup S is not necessarily an equivalence relation.


Since RSR \cup S is not necessarily an equivalence relation, (RS)1(R \cup S)^{-1} is not necessarily an equivalence relation.


The intersection of equivalence relations preserves the equivalence properties, while the union does not.

Therefore, (RS)1(R \cap S)^{-1} is an equivalence relation.

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question