How did the solution assume this?

How come the solution is starting with these statements? What about the exception of one row I did not understand this sol

1

Please log in to comment and participate in discussions.

Comments (2)

  • Total Sum (SnS_n): 810 (Total children)
  • Common Difference (dd): 3 (Since each row has 3 more or fewer than the next)
  • Number of Rows (nn): NN (This is what we need to find)
  • First term (aa): The number of children in the smallest row.

The formula for the sum of an AP is:

Sn=n2[2a+(n−1)d]S_n = \frac{n}{2} [2a + (n-1)d]

810=N2[2a+(N−1)3]810 = \frac{N}{2} [2a + (N-1)3]

1620=N[2a+3(N−1)]1620 = N [2a + 3(N-1)]

2a+3(N−1)=1620N2a + 3(N-1) = \frac{1620}{N}

2a=1620N−3(N−1)2a = \frac{1620}{N} - 3(N-1)


Test the Options:

For a solution to be valid, aa must be a positive integer. This means 2a2a must be an even integer.

Test N=6N = 6:

2a=16206−3(5)=270−15=2552a = \frac{1620}{6} - 3(5) = 270 - 15 = 255

Since 255 is odd, aa would be 127.5127.5 (Not an integer). Invalid.


Test N=8N = 8:

2a=16208−3(7)=202.5−21=181.52a = \frac{1620}{8} - 3(7) = 202.5 - 21 = 181.5

Not an integer. Invalid.


Test N=10N = 10:

2a=162010−3(9)=162−27=1352a = \frac{1620}{10} - 3(9) = 162 - 27 = 135

Since 135 is odd, aa would be 67.567.5. Invalid.


Test N=5N = 5:

2a=16205−3(4)=324−12=3122a = \frac{1620}{5} - 3(4) = 324 - 12 = 312

a=3122=156a = \frac{312}{2} = 156

Since 156 is a whole number, this works! Correct.

Conclusion: Only N=5N = 5 allows for a whole number of children in each row.

1

The phrase "except the last row" is just technical wording.

  • The rule says: "Each row has 3 more children than the row behind it."
  • If you are at the last row, there is no "row behind it." Therefore, the rule cannot be applied to the last row.
  • Conclusion: This simply confirms that all rows follow a consistent pattern (a common difference of 3) until you hit the very back of the group.

In any sequence where numbers change by a constant amount (like 3), the Average of all the numbers has a specific behavior:

Number of Rows (N)Average (810÷N)Why?
If NN is OddMust be an IntegerThe average is exactly equal to the middle row.
If NN is EvenMust end in .5The average is the midpoint between the two middle rows (e.g., between 10 and 13 is 11.5).

Note: Because the difference (dd) is 3 (an odd number), the average for an even number of rows will always end in .5 (like 10.5, 11.5, etc.), never .25 or .0.

We check the total (810) divided by each option (NN):

  • Option (A) N=6N = 6 (Even): 810÷6=135810 \div 6 = 135.Since 6 is even, the result should have ended in .5. This fails.

Option (B) N=8N = 8 (Even): 810÷8=101.25810 \div 8 = 101.25.

  • This is not a .5 value. This fails.

Option (C) N=5N = 5 (Odd): 810÷5=162810 \div 5 = 162.

  • Since 5 is odd, the result must be an Integer. This works!

Option (D) N=10N = 10 (Even): 810÷10=81810 \div 10 = 81.

  • Since 10 is even, the result should have ended in .5. This fails.
2