Why was "geographical confinement" beneficial to the central Egyptian government?

Question

Option 1: It minimized the need for a complex governance structure by forcing all citizens to live in a single city.

Option 2: It provided a natural defence against both land as well as sea-based invasions.

Option 3: It restricted the population to a narrow, observable corridor, facilitating administrative oversight of movement and resources.

Option 4: It allowed for the easy expansion of the Egyptian state into landlocked territories.

AfterBoards · Accepted Answer

From passage: "In a forest or a vast plain, a rebellious group might hide or move. In the Nile Valley, there is nowhere to go but the desert."

Thought Process Breakdown: The question asks why geographical confinement helped the central government. -> The Nile Valley was narrow and linear. -> People could not easily hide or move away. -> Whoever controlled the river controlled transport and communication. -> This made people, land, movement, and resources easier to observe and tax. Option 1 is wrong because citizens did not all live in one city. Option 2 is about defence, not the main point here. Option 4 talks about expansion, not confinement. Option 3 matches the passage.

Option Analysis: 🔴 Option 1 -> Extreme/Unstated -> The passage does not say everyone lived in one city. 🟠 Option 2 -> Plausible but Off-Focus -> Defence is not the reason discussed here. 🟢 Option 3 -> Correct -> The narrow corridor made movement and resources easy to observe and control. 🔴 Option 4 -> Opposite Direction -> The passage is about confinement, not expansion.

IPMAT Indore (VA) PYQs

Keyboard Shortcuts