A review report concludes that Hospital B performed better than Hospital A in treating patients with COVID-19 in terms of the survival rates computed from the data presented in the table below.
Hospital COVID-19 case type Patients Survived A Mild 100 99 A Severe 900 720 B Mild 900 892 B Severe 100 48
Which of the following statements provides the strongest evidence against the conclusion of the report?
A review report concludes that Hospital B performed better than Hospital A in treating patients with COVID-19 in terms of the survival rates computed from the data presented in the table below.
| Hospital | COVID-19 case type | Patients | Survived |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | Mild | 100 | 99 |
| A | Severe | 900 | 720 |
| B | Mild | 900 | 892 |
| B | Severe | 100 | 48 |
Which of the following statements provides the strongest evidence against the conclusion of the report?
Solution
✅ Correct Option: 3
Compute the survival rates:
| Hospital | Mild | Severe | Overall |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | |||
| B |
B looks better overall only because 90% of its patients were mild, while 90% of A's patients were severe. Within the severe group, A is far better (80% against 48%), and the mild rates are almost equal. This is Simpson's paradox: the overall rate is driven by case mix, not quality of treatment.
| Option | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 1 | Supports the report, even if only slightly. |
| 2 | Factually false: B's overall rate is higher. |
| 3 | Points to the case-mix difference that makes the overall comparison misleading. |
| 4 | Both hospitals treated 1000 patients; the count does not affect survival rates. |
Therefore, the answer is option 3.