A state ranks its 600 schools based on the average score of students in the board examination. The teachers from the bottom 50 schools based on last year's rank underwent an intensive teacher-training program. This year, average score of students from those 50 schools improved by 9% on average, while those from the other 550 improved by 2% on average. Officials concluded that the training program is successful.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens that conclusion?
A state ranks its 600 schools based on the average score of students in the board examination. The teachers from the bottom 50 schools based on last year's rank underwent an intensive teacher-training program. This year, average score of students from those 50 schools improved by 9% on average, while those from the other 550 improved by 2% on average. Officials concluded that the training program is successful.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens that conclusion?
Solution
The 50 schools were chosen because they ranked lowest last year. If rankings fluctuate widely, many of them were at the bottom partly due to an unusually bad year. Such schools tend to bounce back towards their normal level the next year anyway (regression to the mean).
So the 9% jump could have happened even without any training, which directly weakens the officials' conclusion.
| Option | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 1 | Offers an alternative explanation for the extra improvement. Weakens most. |
| 2 | Minor and unspecific; no reason it would favour the bottom 50 schools. |
| 3 | The salary rise applied across the state, so it cannot explain the 9% vs 2% gap. |
| 4 | Confirms the other schools are a fair comparison group. Strengthens the conclusion. |
Therefore, the answer is option 1.