A club applies the following five rules to its members.
- Every member who coaches also umpires.
- Every member on the finance panel pays a levy.
- No umpire is on the finance panel.
- No member who pays a levy umpires.
- No member on the finance panel coaches.
Which one of the following rules is/are redundant given the other rules?
(I) Rule 3
(II) Rule 5
A club applies the following five rules to its members.
- Every member who coaches also umpires.
- Every member on the finance panel pays a levy.
- No umpire is on the finance panel.
- No member who pays a levy umpires.
- No member on the finance panel coaches.
Which one of the following rules is/are redundant given the other rules?
(I) Rule 3
(II) Rule 5
Solution
✅ Correct Option: 1
Write each rule as an "if, then" statement:
| Rule | Meaning |
|---|---|
| 1 | Coach → Umpire |
| 2 | Finance → Levy |
| 3 | Finance → Not umpire |
| 4 | Levy → Not umpire |
| 5 | Finance → Not coach |
Rule 3 from the others: Finance → Levy (Rule 2) → Not umpire (Rule 4). So Rule 3 follows from Rules 2 and 4.
Rule 5 from the others: A finance member is not an umpire (Rules 2 and 4). If that member coached, Rule 1 would make them an umpire, a contradiction. So Finance → Not coach, which is Rule 5. It follows from Rules 1, 2 and 4 (Rule 3 is not even needed).
Therefore, both (I) and (II) are redundant.