Skip to main contentSkip to solution

While melatonin supplements may seem like a quick fix for sleep problems, health experts caution against relying on them as a magic long-term solution. The supplements, available in various forms like gummies, pills and liquid, have become increasingly popular among individuals struggling with sleep issues. However, experts advise that they should only be used under medical supervision and for specific purposes.

According to Dr. Neetu Jain, a sleep specialist, melatonin supplements are not effective for individuals with underlying anxiety or depression. "People with these conditions require psychiatric consultation and therapy, such as cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), to address their sleep problems."

CBT is a talking therapy that helps individuals cope with challenges in life by addressing their thought processes. It is a first-line treatment for sleep-related problems before resorting to pharmacological treatments.

Melatonin supplements are most beneficial for individuals with irregular work shifts, those crossing time zones, or individuals recovering from periods of poor sleep patterns. However, experts warn that prolonged use of these supplements can lead to side effects like grogginess and nausea.

Moreover, melatonin supplements are not sedatives or sleep-inducing drugs but rather "physiological supplements" that support the brain in restoring the quality, structure, and pattern of sleep. Experts emphasise the importance of good "sleep hygiene", including avoiding stimulating activities or drinks in the evening, reducing screen time, and engaging in relaxing activities before bed.

Individuals struggling with sleep issues should consult a sleep specialist to determine the underlying cause of their problem and develop a personalised treatment plan.

According to Dr. Neetu Jain, why are melatonin supplements ineffective for individuals with anxiety or depression?

Solution

✅ Correct Option: 1

Option 1 -> Dr. Jain states that people with anxiety or depression require psychiatric consultation and therapy (CBT) to address their sleep problems, not melatonin supplements.

Option 2 -> The passage does not mention that melatonin increases anxiety or depressive symptoms.

Option 3 -> Dr. Jain recommends psychiatric consultation and therapy (CBT), not necessarily stronger medication.

Option 4 -> The passage does not discuss any interaction between melatonin supplements and antidepressants.


Hence, Option 1 -> Dr. Neetu Jain explains that individuals with underlying anxiety or depression need to address the root cause of their sleep problems through psychiatric consultation and therapy like CBT, rather than treating the symptom with sleep aids like melatonin supplements -> correct

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question