Solution
Option 1 -> Ashlyn's gift was not about identifying rare books professionally, but about sensing emotions and echoes from objects, especially books.
Option 2 -> Her special ability was not simply a love of reading, and the vintage boutique is where the current scene takes place, not where she first experienced her gift.
Option 3 -> The passage explicitly states she had "the ability to sense the echoes attached to certain inanimate objects, especially books" and first experienced it at Frank's cramped bookshop after fleeing a parental fight.
Option 4 -> The shock and sadness were what she sensed from The Water-Babies, not the gift itself; and An Unlikely Story is her current bookstore, not where she first discovered her ability.
Hence, Option 3 -> The passage clearly describes her gift as sensing emotions/echoes from books (like "a perfumer's nose"), and she first experienced this strange sensation at Frank's cramped bookshop, which she visited after a fight between her parents, when she picked up The Water-Babies -> correct
More from this set:
Question 3