Skip to main contentSkip to solution

Unless one is wealthy, there is no use in being a charming fellow. Romance is the privilege of the rich, not the profession of the unemployed. The poor should be practical and prosaic. It is better to have a permanent income than to be fascinating. These are the great truths of modern life which Hughie Erskine never realized. Intellectually, he was not of much importance. He never said a brilliant or even ill-natured thing in his life. But he was wonderfully good-looking, as popular with men as he was with women, and had every accomplishment except making money. His father had bequeathed him a cavalry sword and a History of the Peninsular War in fifteen volumes. Hughie hung the first over his looking-glass, put the second on a shelf between Ruff's Guide and Bailey's Magazine, and lived on two hundred a year from an aunt. He had gone on the Stock Exchange for six months; but what was a butterfly to do among bulls and bears? He had been a tea-merchant for a little longer but soon tired of pekoe and souchong. Then he tried selling dry sherry. That did not answer. Ultimately, he became nothing: a delightful, ineffectual young man with a perfect profile and no profession.

To make matters worse, he was in love with Laura Merton, the daughter of a retired Colonel. Laura adored him, and he worshipped her, but neither had a penny to their name. Though the Colonel liked Hughie, he refused to approve their engagement.

Which of the following best describes the tone of the passage?

Solution

✅ Correct Option: 1

Option 1 -> The passage uses irony and wit to mock societal values (e.g., "Romance is the privilege of the rich") and gently ridicules Hughie's ineffectual nature through phrases like "what was a butterfly to do among bulls and bears?" and "delightful, ineffectual young man."

Option 2 -> While not entirely unsympathetic, the narrator maintains an ironic distance rather than expressing genuine sympathy for Hughie's struggles, treating his failures with humor rather than pathos.

Option 3 -> Though the passage mentions Hughie's limited intellectual importance, this is merely one detail in a broader satirical portrait, not the dominant focus of the tone.

Option 4 -> The romantic element is mentioned briefly at the end and treated matter-of-factly rather than being portrayed with romantic sentiment or idealization.


Hence, Option 1: Satirical in its depiction of Hughie's life and circumstances -> The passage employs characteristic satirical devices including ironic opening statements about wealth and romance, witty metaphors about his career failures, and the paradox of being "wonderfully good-looking" yet possessing "every accomplishment except making money" to critique both shallow societal values and Hughie's charming but purposeless existence -> correct

Keyboard Shortcuts

  • Left arrow: Previous question
  • Right arrow: Next question
  • S key: Jump to solution
  • Q key: Jump to question