In each question, a paragraph consists of six sentences. The first and sixth sentences are in their correct positions, while the order of the middle four sentences has been jumbled and numbered (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv). Below each set of sentences are four options indicating the possible order of the four sentences. Choose the option that best makes the six sentences into a logical and coherent paragraph.
First sentence: In one research study, professors Greg Northcraft (University of Illinois) and Margaret Neale (Stanford University) provided real-estate agents with a great deal of information about a house that was for sale.
- (i) The agents then were asked to name an appropriate list price for the house, estimate the house’s appraisal value, state how much a buyer should reasonably pay for the house, and name the lowest offer they would accept for the house if they were the seller.
- (ii) The agents were given randomly chosen list prices—in essence, the seller’s first offer—for the house ranging from $119,000 to $149,000.
- (iii) Agents who were given a higher list price believed the house was worth more than did agents who were given a lower list price.
- (iv) The agents insisted that the random list price they were given did not influence their evaluations, yet their responses suggested that the anchoring effect came into play.
Sixth sentence: Research on the anchoring effect suggests that the party who makes the first offer in a negotiation can gain a powerful advantage by steering talks in her favour.
In each question, a paragraph consists of six sentences. The first and sixth sentences are in their correct positions, while the order of the middle four sentences has been jumbled and numbered (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv). Below each set of sentences are four options indicating the possible order of the four sentences. Choose the option that best makes the six sentences into a logical and coherent paragraph.
First sentence: In one research study, professors Greg Northcraft (University of Illinois) and Margaret Neale (Stanford University) provided real-estate agents with a great deal of information about a house that was for sale.
- (i) The agents then were asked to name an appropriate list price for the house, estimate the house’s appraisal value, state how much a buyer should reasonably pay for the house, and name the lowest offer they would accept for the house if they were the seller.
- (ii) The agents were given randomly chosen list prices—in essence, the seller’s first offer—for the house ranging from $119,000 to $149,000.
- (iii) Agents who were given a higher list price believed the house was worth more than did agents who were given a lower list price.
- (iv) The agents insisted that the random list price they were given did not influence their evaluations, yet their responses suggested that the anchoring effect came into play.
Sixth sentence: Research on the anchoring effect suggests that the party who makes the first offer in a negotiation can gain a powerful advantage by steering talks in her favour.
Solution
Question asks: Arrange (i) to (iv) so the experiment is described in the right order: setup → task → result.
Find the links:
→ First sentence: researchers gave real-estate agents information about a house.
→ (ii) "The agents were given randomly chosen list prices" → adds the key twist of the experiment. It must come right after the setup.
→ (i) "The agents then were asked..." → "then" shows the next step, after they received the information and prices. So (ii) → (i).
→ (iv) The agents claimed the list price did not influence them, "yet their responses suggested" anchoring.
→ (iii) gives the proof: agents shown a higher price valued the house more. So (iv) → (iii): claim, then evidence.
→ The sixth sentence then draws the general lesson about anchoring in negotiations.
Order: (ii) → (i) → (iv) → (iii)
Why the other options are wrong:
Options 2 and 4 start with (iv) → we cannot discuss the agents' responses before they have been given prices and asked anything.
Option 3 (ii, iii, i, iv) → (iii) reports the result before (i) tells us what the agents were asked to do. A result cannot come before the task.
Note: (iii) → (iv) would also read naturally, but no option offers it. Among the given choices, only Option 1 keeps the experiment in the correct order.
Hence, the correct answer is Option 1: (ii), (i), (iv), (iii).